בס'ד
ידל

יום חמישי, אוקטובר 06, 2005
  Cahzon Ish / Extreemisim
On 29/13/5765, at 18:13, Ploni wrote:

Another question. The Chazon Ish who wrote the quote about extremism on your blog.. Is he if it is a he and not a group, Jewish or Muslim? Not a trick question I just can't tell by the name, or if this is a premise you put there because you believe it or can't believe it.


So first off the Chazon Ish or R' Avraham Yeshayahu Karelitz, was a Rabbi of the last generation.

Here is a snip about him from Wikipedia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chazon_Ish)

The reputation of the Chazon Ish for saintliness and knowledge was widespread and people from all walks of life would frequent his home, for scholarly discussions or to seek advice on religious, business, or personal problems, or simply to receive his blessing. When in 1933 he settled in the Land of Israel, his house in Bnei Brak became the address for thousands who sought his guidance.

Holding no official position, the Chazon Ish nevertheless became a recognized worldwide authority on all matters relating to Jewish law and life. He was not appointed as communal leader, yet he exerted an enormous influence on the life and institutions of religious Jewry. He did not publish many responsa, but became the supreme authority on halakha (Jewish law). David Ben-Gurion, the prime minister of Israel, visited him once to discuss political-religious issues.

He belonged to no official movement. He loved and respected all beings and as equally admired by all, without exception – by Hasidim, Mitnagdim, Ashkenazim, Sefardim, Haredim, Datiim, Hilonim, Zionists, and others. Today there is hardly a town in Israel without a street named in his honor. Although essentially an academic scholar, he applied himself to practical problems, devoting much effort to the strengthening of religious life and institutions. His rulings on the use of the milking machine on Shabbat and on cultivation by hydroponics during the sabbatical year are two illustrations of his practical approach. A model of modesty and kindness, the Chazon Ish wrote over 40 books in clear Hebrew, in polished and precise style, which are models of lucidity and brilliance.


Now lets talk about the quote you were referring to.

Extremism is the perfection of the topic. One who waves the banner of moderation and hates extremism, is in the same camp as liars or imbeciles...

First I should say that I can't remember where exactly I heard this, and it is most likely a translation for hebrew, when you translate any thing from hebrew you are losing it's soul.

"The perfection of the topic," any topic, isn't that something we should be striving for?  Don't you want to be the best at your job? If your learning something wouldn't you try to obtain a perfect understanding ? What about a perfect relationship with your spouse? What about perfect love for  humanity ? Who can say that perfection on its own is a bad thing ?

What about the person who says , " I don't want to do a perfect job, a moderate job is what I strive for,"  or "Who needs a perfect relationship with their spouse, a moderate relation ship is all that I want". What do you think about a person like that? The person who only wants a moderate relationship with his spouse, he either must be lying or an idiot. If he says " My wife and I we don't get along as well as we could, but that is ok with me." Who would believe that? He must be lying, to us , and worst to himself. What if he truly believes what he says, and has no desire to improve his relationship? What an idiot !

So you see what the Chazon Ish said, seems to be on target. 

The word "extreme" has been mutilated to deserve a bad connotation, just as we saw, about "Ultra Orthodox", the words "ultra" and "extreme" in themselves aren't bad. It depends on what you put it in front of.

"Extreme Love"  , "Extreme Hate"
"Extremely Smart", "Extremely Stupid"
"Extreme Generosity", "Extremely stingy"

You can think of many more examples I'm sure.  What I think the Chazon Ish was saying is, in what ever you do, strive to be the best, no one should be satisfied with mediocracy. 

Of course you need to chose good causes, any one who says that he is advocating "extreme hate" or "extreme violence" is off.  We should find good goals and then pursue them to the best of our ability. 

I hope your question was answered "Extremely" well.

You should have an "Extremely" good and sweet year.

YDL



 
Comments: הוסף רשומת תגובה

<< Home

I do NOT necessarily endorse any of the ads here from google. If you see any inappropriate ads please leave a comment to a post with the URL of the ad

בס'ד

Please be aware that most of the time I have no idea what I'm talking about, so please follow the links and read the original articles.

*"Extremism is the perfection of the topic. One who waves the banner of moderation and hates extremism, is in the same camp as liars or imbeciles..."
The Chazon Ish

התמונה שלי
שם:
מיקום: Israel
Locations of visitors to this page
ARCHIVES
יוני 2005 / יולי 2005 / אוגוסט 2005 / ספטמבר 2005 / אוקטובר 2005 / נובמבר 2005 / דצמבר 2005 / ינואר 2006 / פברואר 2006 / אפריל 2006 / אוגוסט 2006 /


Powered by Blogger