בס'ד
ידל

יום שישי, ספטמבר 16, 2005
  To Enlist of Not to Enlist

This is from the Machon Meir website... Every week there is something good there but espeicilly this week I think this needs to be seen

Rabbi Elisha Aviner - Education Corner Open Letter to Our Youth: “To Enlist of Not to Enlist”

Recently a petition has been circulating that calls upon youth to forego their army service. This was to be expected. Time after time, our country’s leadership has been warned that their policy is causing a rift in the nation. The heads of the army have been warned that enlisting the army in uprooting Jews from parts of Eretz Yisrael and their massive involvement in the expulsion would lead to profound estrangement from the army. For many, the army is no longer perceived as a people’s army. It has lost its luster. Hence, it is no surprise that young people are speaking negatively about the army and are embarrassed to wear its uniform. The main question is this: Does the present crisis of confidence regarding the army justify not enlisting in it? Is this a proper step? Is it an appropriate response? This grave episode warrants examination from various angles:

1. Israeli army service is a mitzvah. We do not enlist in the army because we support the political steps being taken by the prime minister or his defense minister. We do not enlist because of our enormous admiration for the head of the army or one of the generals in his staff. Rather, we enlist because it is a mitzvah. Enlisting is not a political step that expresses faith in the government or the Knesset. Rather, it is a mitzvah. What mitzvah is it?

First of all, it is a mitzvah to take part in Israel’s compulsory wars defending Israel from its enemies. The Israeli army ensures the safety of the residents of the State of Israel. It is doing this in these very times. It fights terrorists from within, and provides deterrence against the many enemies who surround us from without. Iran, Egypt and Syria are not suspected of excess love for the Jewish People. They sit “quietly” only because of the Israeli Army. Therefore, whoever enlists in the army fulfills the mitzvah of “defending Israel from its enemies,” protecting the state’s inhabitants from slaughter by the enemies of the Jewish People.

The army also ensures Jewish sovereignty over sections of Eretz Yisrael. It is the central vehicle to fulfilling the mitzvah of settling the Land, enabling us “to prevent the Land from being in the hands of any other nation” (Ramban). Even if the army has betrayed its role regarding Gush Katif, it still continues to fulfill its role as far as the rest of Eretz Yisrael, from Kiryat Shemoneh to Eilat. We are angry at the army. We are angry at the heads of the security establishment. That anger is justified. It has to find expression via various kinds of protests, yet that does not free us from fulfilling an important mitzvah relating to the entire Jewish People. G-d has not exempted us from fulfilling this mitzvah.

2. A similar question has been dealt with in the past, and has already been decided by great rabbis of Israel. The question came up in relation to our integration in the Zionish Movement. The Zionist movement not only worked towards Jews moving to Zion, but expressed its position regarding the borders of the Land. It was ready to concede many portions of Eretz Yisrael, and at a certain point it even considered exchanging Eretz Yisrael for Uganda. It formally proclaimed that it had nothing to do with religion, and when the State was first established, it worked against religion and made an effort to distance new immigrants from their religious roots. Therefore, there were those who called for people not to “enlist” in the Zionist Movement, and not to “serve” in its ranks. Yet many great rabbis called upon Jews to join it and to be active in it, due to its contribution towards the redemption of the Jewish People and the return to Zion. We have already mentioned a few times Rabbi Tzvi Yehuda Kook’s interpretation of the Jerusalem Talmud’s words, “Greater is the sanctification of G-d’s name than its profanation.” Isn’t it obvious that the former is greater than the latter? Yet, as Rav Tzvi Yehuda explained, even when G-d’s name is being simultaneously sanctified and profaned, the sanctification wins out. Such thinking led to the decision of many great rabbis in favor of Zionism, as well as to their decision in favor of enlisting in the army. The army’s activities greatly sanctify G-d’s name, and even though they sometimes profane His name as well (as with Jews being expelled from their land, a terrible profanation of His name), the sanctification is decisive.

3. The army is one of the central expressions of Israeli society in the aggregate, perhaps the most central of all. This has led to the deep bond of Israeli society with the army, and to their distaste for anyone who wishes to harm the army or to avoid its ranks. Therefore, whoever cuts himself off from the army cuts himself off from Israeli society. He can proclaim a thousand times over that he feels like part of the State of Israel and Israeli society despite his not having served, but Israeli society does not accept that and does not view him as part of it. In other words, the army is one of the central, tangible expressions of the Jewish People. Whoever sets himself apart from the army, literally sets himself apart from the Jewish People.

This brings us to the profound explanations appearing in Maharal and Rav Kook regarding one’s duty not to set oneself apart from the Jewish People under any circumstances. Maharal stresses that the argument over whether a Jew who sins remains a Jew or not focuses on individual Jews. Regarding the Jewish People in the aggregate, however, even if they worship idols they remain the Jewish People, and we do not cut ourselves off from them. Obviously there are different spiritual levels within the roots of the Jewish People. There is a spiritual hierarchy. Sometimes our people are called “Knesset Yisrael” [the assembly of Israel]; sometimes they are called “Tiferet Yisrael” [the glory of Israel], etc. The Jewish People remain pure and holy at all times. Still, it is not just the ideal “Jewish People” that we have to remain connected to, but also the real-life Jewish People in the flesh, “standing before us today, from the wood carriers to the water drawers.”

4. The petition against enlisting in the army is an expression of anger. Injustice arouses anger and requires a protest. One is allowed to be angry and to protest; it is even a mitzvah to protest. Yet it is forbidden for one’s anger to take control, because it is impossible to build by way of anger. Anger is a destructive force, not a constructive one. In response to the destructive proceedings being carried out by the State’s leadership, we must increase our rebuilding. We must increase our hold on the Land of Israel; our spiritual influence on the State; our social involvement; our rebuilding within the Jewish People, together with the Jewish People. We know that by way of this partnership, we will not encounter just light, but we must maintain it all the same. Let us continue to build within the Jewish People, together with the Jewish People.

Hence, we shall continue enlisting in the army, not because we take lightly what occurred; and not because we are indulgent towards those in the political and security establishment responsible for uprooting part of Eretz Yisrael, but because we feel a responsibility for the State’s future and an obligation to fulfill the Torah’s commandments.

 

יום שלישי, ספטמבר 13, 2005
  Intl_Media_Condemns__Synagogue_Burnings
The U.N. document states, "Holy Places and religious buildings or sites shall be preserved. No act shall be permitted which may in any way impair their sacred character.... Similarly, freedom of worship shall be guaranteed in conformity with existing rights, subject to the maintenance of public order and decorum."

So since that is what the UN document says, Is it a�surprise to see these barbaric acts by the arabs�condemned in the press ?

Consider�the words of the BBC:

Palestinians came streaming to the settlements that caused them so much pain, to sightsee and to loot. Israel stole thirty-eight years from them. Today, many were ready to take back anything they could,"

Wait, what was that ? They�clearly violated a UN agreement and your giving them excuses ? Oh and my british friends aren't you the one's who first occupied that land and�named them them ? They must just have their facts confused... oh and last time I went sight-seeing I didn't set anything on fire, but�apparently that is what the BBC does for holiday.

Let's see if the americans can do any better, (the pillars of morality that they are ), from�Knight-Ridder News:

" 'I want to destroy everything here as they did the Al Aqsa mosque,' said Mahmoud Malahi, who told a reporter he had lost a leg to an Israeli tank when he was 15. 'I want to destroy everything here. It's a symbol of occupation. Destroying it is a symbol of Islam.'"

Oh that poor boy, he is only doing what the jews did to the Al Aqsa.... Hey! Wait A Minute !? How stupid does he think americans are !?"The Al-Aqsa mosque still stands on the Jewish Temple Mount and enjoys the same protected status as Christian and Jewish places of worship." Hasn't he seen a recent picture of Jerusalem ?

The Scotsman news agency reported that the Cabinet decision not to destroy the synagogues "dampened any hopes for a more peaceful era."

Yes if Israel wants any chance at peace they should have wiped them selves out. Shame on you Israel for not making the Arabs do the dirty work of wiping you out! You should have done it yourself!�

I'm so confused, why isn't the media�condemning the arabs for violating the UN agreement? We live in such modern and tollerant times, it can't be that jew-hatred�is still alive and well,� ...... can it ?

*Just a�friendly reminder that you can't trust the media*

more here�
http://www.israelnationalnews.com/news.php3?id=89796�






 

יום שני, ספטמבר 12, 2005
  Wasn't this supposeed to bring peace ?

Isn't this supposed to be the road map to peace ? If so then why are Arab Terror leaders saying "Jihad and attacks are the only way to liberate the occupied lands, not by negotiations.” And why are jewish parents "keeping their children at home in protest over their safety concerns." And why are rocket attacks increasing ?

What happened to the "Peace" that this was supposed to bring ?

 

יום ראשון, ספטמבר 11, 2005
  Religious Questions.

If you are wondering, No! and No!

 

  A new path.

It is the beginning of the month of Elul, a time of tsuvah ( returning ) to the correct path. This is becoming more difficult because more and more of our brothers are disengaging from us. We might not know exactly the right path but each of us as individuals knows witch way doesn't work. If we come together we can help each-other to eliminate all of the wrong paths "and then we can walk together to look for the path leading out."

Here is more from yeshiva.org.il

 

יום רביעי, ספטמבר 07, 2005
  Torn Together
This is worth watching, don't bother reading the comments though.
 

יום שני, ספטמבר 05, 2005
  $20 off at Office Depot

OfficeDepot.com slices $20 off a purchase of $75 or more via coupon code "45036047". Coupon ends September 17. Other OfficeDepot.com coupons are available. tell a friend 

 

יום שישי, ספטמבר 02, 2005
  Re: They have been sucked into the sin of the Spies
First Spies is referring to a specific set of Spies ( summary )  talked about in the Chumash. The simplified story is that before the Am Yisrael (Nation of Israel, The jews )  went into Eretz Yisrael ( the land of Israel ), they wanted to send spies into the land, these spies were made up mostly of the leaders of the nation. The spies came back with a negative report to discourage the people and discourage them from entering the land. ( except for 2 Kalev Ben Yfune, and Yhosuah Ben Nun). Because of what they did they were forbidden to enter the land until that whole generation died. This is a very over simplification. This is an important ( although tragic) event in jewish history. 

When I wrote this It was just to clear up something that I misunderstood and maybe other people did too. I missed an important point of the quote. "they have been sucked into the sin of the Spies." Originally I saw the religious jews who didn't consider living in israel as important  as being hypocritical and just missing the point. What I missed was that they have been tricked, they just don't see or understand what they are doing. Kind of like a blind person walking off a cliff. They are surrounded by things that confuse them even when it is so clear. So I was trying to point out is that those who can see clearly should feel sorry for those who can't, like a drug addict. You don't hate him for destroying his body, you feel sorry for him.

As for "eternal truth," I don't really understand what you expect me to say ? When you write a paper on physics you don't go back and derive things from first principles every time for those who don't know the "basics," you expect them to accept certain things, even if it is just temporarily for the sake of understanding your material. If some one tells you "I don't believe in calculus, you have to explain this to me in a way were there is no calculus involved." You can give him a very superficial explanation but he will be really missing many of the pivotal points. 

I'm  not writing any of this to try to convince any one of my "eternal truths" I'm writing my opinion, and if someone wants to understand then they should accept that what I'm writing is based on a set of principles. If there is a principle that is not clear I'm happy to ( try to) explain it ( and explain my logic) but I can't make any one believe something that they don't want to. If some one doesn't want to believe in my principles then they can accept them as theory for the sake of the article (  even though I know they aren't theories ).

If you notice "Achronim" and "Giants of the World" is from a quote, not something I wrote on my own. I was attempting to explain the quote, and clarify something that was unclear to me. 

I hate to point this out but "world will turn its back" no matter what Israel does. There are so many worse things going on in the world, but you see that Israel gets more attention than any of that. Why was this disengagement on the front page of even the secular american papers. I'm sure that there was some domestic issue that was of much more importance to the well being of average american non-jew.  The fact is that the nations ( in general ) have a condition called Sinat-Yisrael . This is a genetic disease that they have, some times it flares up and is worse than others, but it is always there, it is one of those "eternal truths".

What is worse is that even some of Am Yisrael is catching this disease, and it happens from time to time. In jews this is a dangerous allergy to any thing jewish. It is an allergy to something that is essential for their well being. Some jews have more extreme cases where they need to distance them selves from even a  hint of Yhadut. But most jews these days have a more mild form where they just have an intolerance to larger quantities, the cure for this is just more exposure, this will built up a tolerance. 

The 'believers" do not want to separate them selves from the "non-believers". There are times when the believers get discouraged by the actions of the "non-believers." The point I was trying to make was that even when the "non-believers" give the "believers" reason to separate, the "believers" need to understand that the "non-believers" are confused and blinded by their condition, and that they need help, and not to be pushed away. We can see from this awful thing that just happened that the "believers" are trying their hardest to love and connect with the "non-believers."

I hope this cleared up any confusion... 
On 28/12/5765, at 07:06, Ploni wrote:

Yisrael -

Why is Spies capitalized?  Who are they spying on?  The words are all presented as emanating from an eternal truth which most can’t understand or related to.   If it is meant to convince only those who already believe in that truth, why bother?  If it is meant to convince or educate others, then trying to do on the basis of faith won’t reach those outside the belief system.  Most people don’t know who Achronim is – and when you say Giants of the World – it doesn’t register.  People won’t respond.  The Jews have to solidify and fortify a strong nation that is beyond reproach – they need the help of even the “non-believers” to survive.  If terrorist rockets kill children – even the non-believers will be outraged.  If Israelis kill children, even in self-defense, the world will turn its back.

~Ploni 
 
בס'ד

Please be aware that most of the time I have no idea what I'm talking about, so please follow the links and read the original articles.

*"Extremism is the perfection of the topic. One who waves the banner of moderation and hates extremism, is in the same camp as liars or imbeciles..."
The Chazon Ish

התמונה שלי
שם:
מיקום: Israel
Locations of visitors to this page
ARCHIVES
יוני 2005 / יולי 2005 / אוגוסט 2005 / ספטמבר 2005 / אוקטובר 2005 / נובמבר 2005 / דצמבר 2005 / ינואר 2006 / פברואר 2006 / אפריל 2006 / אוגוסט 2006 /


Powered by Blogger